Free Consultation
Free Consultation
Contract dispute mediation is a structured negotiation process in which a neutral third party helps businesses and individuals resolve breach of contract claims without litigation.
Joseph P. Farina, retired Chief Judge of Florida’s 11th Judicial Circuit and Florida Supreme Court Certified Circuit Civil Mediator at JAMS, mediates contract disputes across Miami-Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach counties.
Farina brings 30+ years of judicial experience to every session.
Protect your business relationship and resolve your contract dispute faster — schedule a mediation with Judge Farina today.
A contract dispute arises when one party to a binding agreement fails to perform an obligation required by the agreement. Florida recognizes contract disputes involving both written and oral agreements across commercial, real estate, employment, and service-based transactions.
Florida courts require four elements for a contract to be enforceable: mutual assent (offer and acceptance), consideration (an exchange of value), legal capacity of both parties, and a lawful purpose.
Contracts for the sale of goods priced at $500 or more must also satisfy the writing requirement under Florida’s Uniform Commercial Code, § 672.201.
Oral agreements remain enforceable for transactions below that threshold, though proving their terms in court becomes significantly harder without written documentation.
Miami’s commercial environment generates contract disputes across multiple industries.
The most common categories include vendor and supplier disputes, partnership dissolution disputes, franchise agreement violations, service contract failures, and breaches of non-compete or non-disclosure clauses.
Real estate purchase agreement disputes and construction contract conflicts also account for a significant share of commercial mediation referrals in South Florida.
A breach of contract occurs when one party fails to fulfill a contractual obligation — whether by delivering nonconforming goods, missing a payment deadline, or refusing to perform entirely. Florida law distinguishes between two categories of breach: material and non-material.
A material breach defeats the purpose of the agreement and entitles the non-breaching party to suspend performance and seek damages.
A non-material breach involves a minor deviation that does not compromise the contract’s core purpose — the injured party may recover damages but cannot walk away from the agreement entirely.
| Breach Type | Definition | Effect on Contract | Available Remedies |
| Material Breach | Failure that defeats the contract’s purpose | The non-breaching party may cancel and seek full damages | Compensatory damages, consequential damages, contract cancellation |
| Non-Material Breach | Minor deviation from agreed terms | Contract remains in force; breaching party must cure | Compensatory damages only; no cancellation right |
| Anticipatory Breach | Clear refusal to perform before the deadline | The non-breaching party may treat it as an immediate material breach | Compensatory damages cover costs and contract cancellation |
| Partial Breach | Incomplete performance of one obligation | Remaining obligations still enforceable | Damages limited to the unperformed portion |
Florida imposes strict deadlines for filing breach of contract lawsuits. Written contract claims carry a five-year statute of limitations under § 95.11(2)(b). Oral contract claims allow a 4-year period under § 95.11(3)(j).
UCC sale-of-goods claims carry a separate four-year period under § 672.725. The clock starts at the moment of breach — not when the injured party discovers the violation. Missing these deadlines permanently bars the claim, so parties with pending disputes should act promptly.
Mediation resolves contract disputes through structured negotiation rather than adversarial courtroom proceedings. The process typically concludes in 1–2 days, compared to civil lawsuits that often take over a year to reach trial in Florida circuit courts.
Litigation requires depositions, document production, evidentiary hearings, and trial preparation — each phase adding legal fees that often exceed the value of the underlying dispute.
Mediation eliminates those procedural costs while preserving the parties’ ability to craft creative solutions that a court cannot order, including revised contract terms, structured payment plans, and continued business relationships.
| Factor | Litigation | Mediation |
| Average Timeline | Often exceeds 12 months to trial | 1–2 days |
| Cost | Attorney fees, court costs, depositions, expert witnesses | Mediator fee split between parties |
| Confidentiality | Public court record | Protected under Florida § 44.405 |
| Outcome Control | A judge or jury decides | Parties control the resolution |
| Business Relationship | Adversarial, often destroys working relationships | Collaborative: preserves ongoing partnerships |
| Enforceability | Court judgment | Signed settlement agreement enforceable in court |
Your contract dispute does not have to end a business relationship — contact Judge Farina to explore resolution through mediation.
Florida’s mediation process follows a structured sequence designed to move parties from entrenched positions toward mutual resolution. Under Florida Statute § 44.102, a court must refer any filed civil action for monetary damages to mediation when a party requests a referral and agrees to share the costs. Parties may also initiate mediation voluntarily before filing suit.
Each party submits a confidential mediation summary outlining the contract terms at issue, the alleged breach, and the desired resolution. The mediator reviews these summaries, the relevant contract documents, and any supporting evidence before the session begins.
The mediator opens with an explanation of the mediation ground rules, confidentiality protections, and the voluntary nature of the process. Each party’s attorney presents an opening statement summarizing the dispute from their client’s perspective.
The mediator meets with each party separately in private rooms. These caucus sessions allow the mediator to explore underlying interests, assess the strengths and weaknesses of each position, and develop settlement options without the adversarial pressure of a joint setting. The mediator moves between rooms, conveying offers, counteroffers, and creative proposals.
When the parties reach an agreement, the mediator drafts a written settlement document that both parties sign during the session. The signed agreement becomes a binding contract enforceable in Florida courts.
If the parties reach an impasse on one or more issues, the mediator reports the outcome to the court without disclosing any substantive details of the negotiations.
Florida’s Mediation Confidentiality and Privilege Act, codified in §§ 44.401–44.406, provides statutory protections for all communications made during mediation. Under § 44.405, all mediation communications are confidential by statute.
Mediation participants cannot disclose session content to anyone outside the mediation, and a mediation party has a statutory privilege to refuse to testify about mediation communications in any subsequent proceeding.
The § 44.405 protections apply to oral statements, written documents, and nonverbal conduct made during the mediation or in furtherance of mediation before the session begins.
The statute includes limited exceptions for criminal activity, mandatory abuse reporting, and professional misconduct — but the core protection ensures that parties can negotiate candidly without fear that their statements will be used against them in future litigation.
A signed settlement agreement reached during mediation is not confidential unless the parties explicitly agree otherwise, and the agreement is enforceable as a binding contract in Florida courts.
Judge Farina mediates the full spectrum of commercial contract disputes through JAMS, including business partnership and joint venture disputes, vendor and supplier delivery failures, franchise agreement violations, professional services contract disputes, and breaches of non-compete and confidentiality clauses.
Farina’s mediation practice also covers real estate purchase and lease disputes, construction contract conflicts, employment agreement disputes, and HOA covenant violations across Miami-Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach counties.
Judge Farina’s 30+ years on the bench in Miami-Dade County included presiding over complex commercial dockets, mass tort litigation, and multi-party business disputes.
The 2016 Dade County Bar Association recognized Farina with its Legal Luminary Mediation Award as “Best Mediator” for Miami-Dade County.
Mediation sessions are available in person at 600 Brickell Avenue, Suite 2600, Miami, FL 33131, or virtually via Zoom, Microsoft Teams, or WebEx.
A breach of contract should not cost more to resolve than the contract itself is worth — schedule your mediation with Judge Farina and move toward resolution today.
What is contract dispute mediation?
Contract dispute mediation is a voluntary process in which a neutral mediator helps parties resolve breach of contract claims outside of court. The mediator facilitates communication, identifies common ground, and guides parties toward a binding settlement agreement without litigation costs.
How long does a contract mediation session take?
Most contract mediations conclude within 1–2 days, with a single session lasting four to eight hours, depending on the complexity of the dispute and the number of parties involved. Multi-party or high-value commercial disputes may require a second day to resolve.
Is mediation legally required before filing a breach of contract lawsuit in Florida?
Florida does not mandate pre-suit mediation for most contract disputes. Under § 44.102, a court must refer a civil action to mediation when one party requests referral and agrees to cover costs. Commercial contracts often include mandatory mediation clauses requiring the process before litigation.
Are statements made during mediation confidential?
Florida Statute § 44.405 makes all mediation communications confidential. Participants cannot disclose session content to third parties, and mediation statements are inadmissible in any subsequent court proceeding, with limited statutory exceptions for criminal activity and mandatory abuse-reporting obligations.
Can a mediated settlement agreement be enforced in court?
A signed settlement agreement reached during mediation becomes a binding contract under Florida law. Either party may enforce the agreement by moving in the referring court or by filing a breach-of-contract action if the other party fails to comply.
What happens if the parties do not reach an agreement in mediation?
The mediator declares impasse and reports to the court that no agreement was reached, without disclosing substantive details of the negotiations. The parties retain all rights to pursue litigation, arbitration, or future mediation, and nothing disclosed during the process may be used in court.
How much does contract mediation cost in Miami?
JAMS mediator fees for contract disputes vary based on session complexity and duration. Parties typically split the fee equally, though the referring court may allocate costs differently. One mediation day typically costs less than a single round of depositions in a comparable civil lawsuit.
Who chooses the mediator in a contract dispute?
Parties typically select a mediator by mutual agreement, often consulting JAMS resolution advisor recommendations, Florida Bar referrals, or attorney recommendations. Florida Statute § 44.102 requires the chief judge of each judicial circuit to maintain a certified mediator list for court-ordered referrals.
What qualifications does Judge Farina bring to contract mediation?
Judge Farina spent over 30 years on the Miami-Dade bench, including 14 years as Chief Judge supervising the circuit’s 123 judges across 10 courthouses. He received the 2016 Dade County Bar Association Legal Luminary Mediation Award and mediates contract disputes full-time through JAMS.
Can I mediate a contract dispute before filing a lawsuit?
Pre-suit mediation is available for any contract dispute in Florida. Parties may voluntarily enter mediation at any stage — before filing suit, during litigation, or even post-judgment. Early mediation often produces faster resolutions and lower costs because the dispute has not yet escalated through adversarial discovery.
